Common Causes and Mistakes Leading to the Rejection of an Article and How to Avoid Them

One of the main reasons of rejection of an article is issues with its structure, subject, and inappropriate translation. You should know that rejection is common in scientific journals.


Based on Statistics, 62% of published articles have been rejected by journal reviewers at least once. It is interesting to know that at least 50% of the rejected articles are published after 2 years of this incidence.
Researchers evaluate the quality of articles based on two main criteria:

  • Research subject falling within the scope of the journal
  • Research design quality

Important Reasons for Rejection of Articles

The articles are technically reviewed, even before being reviewed by the Chief Editor. The main reasons for rejection at this step are as follows:

  • The article is suspected of plagiarism or is currently being reviewed in another journal. (Publishing the whole or parts of the article again, submitting it simultaneously to one or more journals, or using unauthorized text and images is not permitted).
  • The article is incomplete; it may lack key sections such as title, authors’ names, or affiliations (i.e., from which academic center or organization you are submitted your article), keywords, body of the article, references, tables, and figures.
  • The level of written English is not good enough for the reviewing process.
  • The figures are incomplete or not clear enough to be studied.
  • The text does not follow the authors’ guidelines provided by the journal.
  • References are not complete or are too old.

The article is not within the scope of the journal

Many authors who are interested in publishing their paper usually send the paper to the journal before thoroughly reviewing the paper, and once the article is referred to the referees in the first step. Thus, knowing the scopes and areas of interest for the journal is essential.

Insignificance of the Research Topic

Research topic plays an important role in the acceptance of a scientific paper. If your scholarly article is not attractive enough for readers, it is very likely that your article will be rejected by the editor in chief. Sometimes a scientific article is a small part of another article that has already been published, which increases the likelihood of an article being rejected.

Selecting the Wrong Journal

You have to be very careful in choosing the right journal that matches the subject of your article. In some cases, your article does not fall within the scope of the journal’s scientific activities.

Editing Error

One of the common reasons for quick rejection of the articles is problems with the English language of the article. In this case, the editors usually point out the general problems of the English of the paper in their response. They usually encourage the researchers to have their article edited by a native or professional editor. For this purpose, you can use DoNotEdit English editing services, to make sure that your paper is free of any language-related mistakes. Sometimes this kind of rejection is valid and justifiable so that the article is accepted after editing.

Was this post helpful?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Skip to toolbar